Post by whitewolfstark on Mar 21, 2016 3:12:09 GMT
In the Joffrey/Cersei scene, I can see why they had Joffrey say that there should be a professional army loyal to the crown alone. It's a way to introduce feudal system logistics to the viewing audience who might have a poor understanding of how such a system works--but Joffrey's ideas are very revolutionary from an in-world perspective and his failing to understand how a feudalistic society works when he's a Prince trained to exploit such a system marks me as a bit unbelievable. Were Joffrey younger, I could believe his needing to be schooled, but at his age in the show I find it harder to believe.
In fact, let me say that at the end of the Wars of the Roses, the reforms that Joffrey are spouting out are exactly what Henry VII implemented in order to prevent future dynastic wars from occurring by disbanding the use of personal livery and other similar such reforms which put England on the path to having a professional army.
So Joffrey's ideas are revolutionary, and what this entire conflict in ASOIAF should inspire to occur at the end of the series--were it true to the history that inspired it.
In the Joffrey/Cersei scene, I can see why they had Joffrey say that there should be a professional army loyal to the crown alone. It's a way to introduce feudal system logistics to the viewing audience who might have a poor understanding of how such a system works--but Joffrey's ideas are very revolutionary from an in-world perspective and his failing to understand how a feudalistic society works when he's a Prince trained to exploit such a system marks me as a bit unbelievable. Were Joffrey younger, I could believe his needing to be schooled, but at his age in the show I find it harder to believe.
In fact, let me say that at the end of the Wars of the Roses, the reforms that Joffrey are spouting out are exactly what Henry VII implemented in order to prevent future dynastic wars from occurring by disbanding the use of personal livery and other similar such reforms which put England on the path to having a professional army.
So Joffrey's ideas are revolutionary, and what this entire conflict in ASOIAF should inspire to occur at the end of the series--were it true to the history that inspired it.
Joffrey has a couple really smart ideas but stupidity implemented.
Darkstar will be the next Vulture King.
Craster has 19 daughters and there are 19 castles on the Wall, coincidence I think not!
but Joffrey's ideas are very revolutionary from an in-world perspective and his failing to understand how a feudalistic society works when he's a Prince trained to exploit such a system marks me as a bit unbelievable. Were Joffrey younger, I could believe his needing to be schooled, but at his age in the show I find it harder to believe.
But aren't we almost supposed to see Joffrey as an idiot on a bit of a power trip. He believes himself to be capable of much more than he actually is.
In fact, let me say that at the end of the Wars of the Roses, the reforms that Joffrey are spouting out are exactly what Henry VII implemented in order to prevent future dynastic wars from occurring by disbanding the use of personal livery and other similar such reforms which put England on the path to having a professional army.
Which makes me wonder. Is this part of an idea that we should be keeping in the back of our minds for an end scenario?
So Joffrey's ideas are revolutionary, and what this entire conflict in ASOIAF should inspire to occur at the end of the series--were it true to the history that inspired it.
::i agree:: And next time I should read the entire comment before replying.