Post by Maester Sam on Sept 7, 2016 0:18:32 GMT
I am sure, because the godswood and the crypts and even Winterfell and the way well the North is described is in similar terms. A good example is to read the chapter with Robert visiting the crypts. Robert's speech on the stairs about Highgarden and the hot days in King's Landing is a speech that celebrates life: taste, sound, sight, smell, while the crypts are dark, cold, and silent and immobile. If you then flip back to Catelyn's first chapter a little before that where she enters the godswood, the godswood is described in the same way as the crypts: dark, brooding, silent, gods with no names versus her memory of the godswood in Riverrun where there's light, and water sounds, birds singing, air, smell of flowers and the faith with its gods that have faces and names and a rainbow of colors. Then you go to her second chapter and that's her haven (whereas the godswood is Ned's haven), where it's always hot, and where her children were born and made (fertility), while Ned opens the window to look out into the "night" and let the "cold air" in. Most people from the North (South of the Wall) simply don't often go South of the Neck themselves. Or we have Theon having a type of Walhalla dream at Winterfell with all the fallen heroes. The bannermen and common folk of the North are good "souls" that tend to stay where they belong - North. And they don't get many visitors from the South either. Of course after things go wrong, the RL is slowly turned into an underworld too, and by aFfC it's Hel and a bit of Purgatory. I think we'll soon count the Vale as annexed by the underworld too imo in tWoW.
Yes, when you put it that way, Winterfell obviously has to be a part of it. Which makes the Wall irrelevant as a demarcation line, and then it should be the whole North since it's clearly a land to itself. You have convinced me- thank you for the helpful explanation!